Level 4 · Advanced Evidence & Argumentation

Separate fact from persuasion.

Level 4 trains you to do what an equivalency test demands at the highest level: read multiple conflicting sources, identify bias and fallacies, synthesize evidence across texts, evaluate scientific claims, and write extended responses that cite specific evidence. This is the bridge from "I can do the work" to "I can think like a college student and a test-taker."

You now have the tools. Level 4 teaches you to use them with precision under pressure. One source, one claim, one paragraph at a time.

How are you working today?

Pick one. You can change it any time.

Before we start · 7 questions · 10 minutes

Let's see where you are.

This diagnostic is a map, not a grade: seven questions, each one a fair sample of what Level 4 will ask you to do with evidence and argument. Guess if you don't know. Missing questions here is the point: every miss marks exactly where your work in this level begins.

Diagnostic 1 Reading · Inference
The letter had sat on the table for six days. Each morning Renata moved it (under the sugar tin, behind the radio, once into the drawer with the batteries) and each morning she found it again and put it back. On the seventh day she carried it to the window, held it up to the light without opening it, and set it down again.

The passage most strongly suggests that Renata —
Inference is built from the actions the writer chose to show, not from what a character says. Notice that she does two opposite things over and over: she keeps the letter within reach, and she keeps not opening it. Ask what state of mind produces both at once.
Diagnostic 2 Reading · Author's purpose
For most of the twentieth century, the phrase sick building was a joke. Then, in 1976, an outbreak traced to a Philadelphia hotel's cooling system killed dozens of people who had gathered there for a convention. Engineers who had spent their careers sealing buildings tighter began, reluctantly, to study how air moves through them.

The author mentions that the engineers had spent their careers sealing buildings tighter mainly in order to —
A purpose question asks why a detail is in the paragraph, not what the detail states. Cover the phrase and see what the paragraph loses. Then look at the nearby word the author could have left out (an adverb describing how the engineers took up the work) and ask what it is doing.
Diagnostic 3 Writing · Argument structure
A writer argues: Cities should replace their oldest street lights with LED lamps. LEDs use far less electricity and last several times longer than the bulbs they replace. Critics point out that the new lamps cast a harsher light that some residents dislike.

Which sentence would most effectively complete this argument?
Read the last sentence of the argument before you read the options. The writer has handed the reader an objection, which means the argument now owes the reader an answer to it. Piling on more support for a point already made, or waving the objection away, leaves that debt unpaid.
Diagnostic 4 Writing · Sentence editing
Choose the best revision of this sentence:

Having been rewired only last spring, the inspector found no fault in the building's electrical system.
An opening phrase like this attaches to whatever noun follows it, whether the writer meant it to or not. Name the thing that was actually rewired, then find the subject of the main clause. When those two differ, moving the phrase around is not enough: the sentence has to be rebuilt.
Diagnostic 5 Math · Percent change
A city bus route carried 1,200 riders last Monday. The following Monday, ridership was 15% lower than that. The Monday after that, ridership rose 15% from the second Monday's total.

How many riders did the route carry on the third Monday?
Each percent applies to the number that comes right before it, not to the original number. Work one Monday at a time and write down the new total before you use the second percent: a percent taken off a smaller number and then added back to that smaller number does not return you to where you started.
Diagnostic 6 Math · Linear relationship
A seedling's height is measured every two weeks and grows at a steady rate.

Week  |  Height (cm)
2  |  11
4  |  17
6  |  23
8  |  29

If the seedling keeps growing at this rate, how tall will it be at week 12?
First find how much the height changes per week, not per row: the weeks jump by two each time. Then count how many weeks lie between the last measurement and the week you are asked about. Check what the table implies about week 0 before scaling anything up.
Diagnostic 7 Science · Evaluating evidence
A researcher writes: In a survey of 900 adults, those who reported sleeping fewer than six hours a night were twice as likely to report frequent headaches as those who slept seven to eight hours. Short sleep therefore causes headaches.

Which statement identifies the strongest weakness in this conclusion?
The evidence here is two things measured at the same time in the same people. Before accepting the stated direction of cause, try running the arrow backwards and see whether the data would look any different. If the survey cannot tell the two stories apart, that is the weakness.
Module I · 35 points · Two sources, seven questions

Two accounts of the same bus line

Two writers describe the same transit redesign and come away with different conclusions about it. Your job is not to pick a side: it is to track exactly where they agree, where they part, and what each source can actually prove.

What you'll do: read two sources on one subject, find the fact neither disputes, locate the point where they separate, and decide which source can carry a given claim.

Passage 1counts and reviewsPassage 2one rider's accountWhat itoffersCounts: trip times,boardings, job reachHer own mornings onthe 3:52 busCan proveCannotproveThe fact neither writer disputes:The point where they part:Dashed boxes are yours to fill in.
Picture it Compare the two accounts: prove, agree, part

After you read both passages, fill the dashed boxes. What can a count prove, and what can one rider's story prove? Then name the fact both accept and where they split.

Passage 1 · Informational

Twenty-two stations, ten minutes saved

When the K Line opened along Chicago Avenue in April 2024, the county transit authority called it the largest change to south-side bus service in thirty years. The new line took over most of the path of local Route 12. Where Route 12 stopped every two blocks, K Line buses stop about every third of a mile, at raised platforms where riders pay before boarding rather than at the farebox. On weekdays a bus comes every ten minutes from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m., every twenty minutes from 4:30 to 6 a.m. and from 7 to 11:30 p.m., and every thirty-five minutes overnight.

After one year, the authority's counts show the average weekday trip from 46th Street to downtown falling from thirty-four minutes to twenty-four. Weekday boardings rose from roughly 13,000 to 18,400, an increase of about 41 percent. An independent review by the Regional Mobility Institute confirmed both figures using automated passenger counters installed on every bus.

The Institute also measured what it calls job reach: the number of jobs a corridor resident can get to in a forty-five-minute ride without transferring. That number rose from about 61,000 to about 88,000. The researchers noted that their model used trips beginning between 7 and 9 a.m., which they described as "the window in which the largest share of regional commutes begin."

The gains required consolidation. Seventy-four local stops became twenty-two stations. The authority estimates that about 1,900 daily riders now board farther from home than they used to, some by as much as half a mile. A survey mailed to households along the former Route 12, returned by 640 riders, found that 8 percent described the walk to their new station as "difficult or unsafe in winter conditions."

Overnight service was not part of the redesign. Between 11:30 p.m. and 4:30 a.m., buses on the corridor run at the same thirty-five-minute interval they ran before the K Line opened. At a February 2025 briefing, agency planners said overnight frequency would be studied in a later phase of the project.

Average trip, 46th St todowntown3424BeforeAfter10 minutes shorterWeekday boardings13,00018,400BeforeAfterabout 41 percent moreJobs within a 45-minute ride,no transfer61,00088,000BeforeAfterabout 27,000 more jobsStops along the route7422BeforeAfter52 fewer stopsEach box has its own scale. Counts are weekday counts; the job count uses 7 to 9 a.m. trips.
Picture it Passage 1 in four before and after counts

Passage 1 reports gains in time, riders and jobs, and a loss in stops. Notice the note at the bottom: when the job count was measured, and for which trips.

Passage 2 · First-person account

What the 3:52 looks like

I have ridden the bus down Chicago Avenue for eleven years, and I want to be careful about what I say, because I have heard people at these meetings say things that are not true, and it costs the rest of us our credibility.

Here is what is true for me. My shift in the hospital kitchen starts at 5:00 a.m. Overnight, the buses come every thirty-five minutes, so my choices are the 3:52 and the 4:27. The 4:27 puts me downtown at 4:53: seven minutes to cross two blocks, badge in, and tie an apron. I have tried it. Twice it did not work, and the second time I was written up. So I take the 3:52. It puts me there at 4:16, and I stand in a service corridor for thirty-eight minutes, five mornings a week, and have since April.

My old stop was outside my door at 41st. The station now is at 38th, which is six blocks, and in January those six blocks have two working streetlights and a knee that does not care for February.

They mailed a survey. I know, because my neighbor got one. I moved apartments in October and again in March, both times within four blocks, and no survey ever caught up with me. The riders whose walk got hardest are very often the riders whose addresses do not sit still.

I read that the study looked at trips starting between seven and nine in the morning. That is a fair window if your morning starts then. Mine starts while the building is still dark.

I am not asking anyone to tear out the platforms. Coming home I am twelve minutes faster, and twelve minutes is how I now reach my sister's place before she leaves for her own shift, so my grandson is not sitting on a step. Those minutes are real, and I would not give them back. What I am saying is that the gain is narrow: it fits the riders they measured, during the hours they measured, and then it stops. Widen the window and you will find the rest of us standing in it.

Overnight, buses come every 35 minutesChoice 1: the 3:52 bus (what she takes)3:52Bus leaves4:16Downtown38 minWaits in aservicecorridor5:00Shift startsShe is early, every morning since April.Choice 2: the 4:27 bus4:27Bus leaves4:53Downtown7 minCross twoblocks, badgein, tie apron5:00Shift startsShe tried it. Twice it did not work.
Picture it Two overnight buses to a 5:00 a.m. shift

Follow each lane left to right. The new line is faster, yet neither overnight bus fits her shift well. Notice what each choice costs her.

Question 1 Reading · Purpose
The author of Passage 1 organizes the passage mainly in order to
Notice what the last two paragraphs do that the first three do not. A statement of purpose has to account for the whole passage, not only the part that is most memorable.
Question 2 Reading · Inference
Based on Passage 1, which statement about the drop in average trip time is best supported?
Two separate facts in the passage (how far apart the buses stop now, and how far some riders have to walk) describe a single design decision. Ask what one decision could produce both results.
Question 3 Reading · Tone
Which best describes the writer's attitude toward the K Line in Passage 2?
Find the sentences where she gives the project credit, then read the sentence that comes directly after each one. The relationship between those two moves is the tone.
Question 4 Reading · Vocabulary
In the last paragraph of Passage 2, the writer says the gain is narrow. As she uses it, narrow most nearly means
She defines the word herself in the clause that follows it. Read to the end of the sentence before you decide which everyday meaning of the word fits here.
Question 5 Reading · Synthesis
Which statement best describes the relationship between the two passages?
Before deciding where two writers split, find the fact neither of them argues with. Passage 2 concedes something about speed: locate that concession first.
Question 6 Reading · Conflicting evidence
Passage 1 reports that 8 percent of surveyed riders called the walk to their new station "difficult or unsafe in winter conditions." How does Passage 2 most directly complicate that figure?
She tells a small story about her own mail. Ask what that story implies about who ends up counted inside a mailed survey's results and who does not.
Question 7 Reading · Using sources
A reader wants to support the claim that the redesign expanded the range of jobs corridor residents can reach on a single bus. Which source better supports that claim, and why?
The claim is about a measured range of jobs, not about how many people ride or how one commute feels. Look for the sentence that counts the exact thing the claim names.
Module II · 30 points · Six questions + extended response

Building an argument that holds

An argument is a structure: a claim you can defend, evidence a reader can check, and an honest answer to the strongest objection against you. This module works on that structure, and on the sentence-level control that keeps a reader with you instead of stopping to reread.

What you'll do: find the claim inside a paragraph, tell evidence from opinion, answer a counterclaim without collapsing, fix three sentence faults, and write an argument of your own.

Question 1 Writing · Identifying the claim
Read this paragraph from a letter to a county board.

(1) Last spring the county cut service on the Route 22 bus from every fifteen minutes to every forty minutes. (2) Since then, riders on that line have arrived late often enough that two employers along the route have stopped hiring from the neighborhood entirely. (3) The county should return Route 22 to its old schedule. (4) Reliable transportation matters to everyone.

Which sentence states the writer's claim?
A claim is the one sentence the rest of the paragraph is trying to get you to agree to. It says what should happen or what is true, and a reasonable person could push back on it. Background facts set the scene, and broad statements everybody already agrees with are support at best.
Question 2 Writing · Evidence vs. opinion
A student is writing about whether the city should keep the neighborhood rec center open until 10 p.m. Which sentence is evidence rather than opinion?
Evidence is something a reader could go check: a count, a date, a record, a named source. Watch for sentences that borrow the sound of proof (anyone can see, most people would agree) without pointing at anything anyone could look up.
Question 3 Writing · Answering a counterclaim
A student is arguing that the school should keep its library open on Saturday mornings. A reader raises this counterclaim: Staffing the library on Saturday would cost money the school does not have.

Which sentence best answers that counterclaim?
A good answer to a counterclaim does two jobs: it treats the objection as real, then shows why it does not sink the argument: usually with something specific the reader can weigh. If your sentence waves the objection away, or agrees with it and stops, the argument is weaker after that sentence than before.
Question 4 Writing · Parallel structure
A worker drafts this sentence in a cover letter:

In my last job I was responsible for opening the store, restocking the cooler, and I trained two new employees.

Which revision corrects the faulty parallel structure?
When a sentence lists two or three things, every item has to be built the same way. Read the words that introduce the list, then each item on its own. The item that suddenly needs a new subject or a different verb form is the one breaking the pattern.
Question 5 Writing · Dangling modifiers
A tenant drafts this sentence in a letter to a landlord:

Standing in the kitchen, the smell of gas was strong enough to make me dizzy.

Which revision corrects the dangling modifier?
An opening phrase that starts with an -ing word hands its action to whoever the sentence names next. Ask who was really doing that action, then either put that person right after the comma or rebuild the phrase into a full clause that names them.
Question 6 Writing · Comma splices
An applicant writes this on a housing application:

I have worked at the same warehouse for three years, my supervisor has agreed to confirm that in writing.

Which revision corrects the comma splice?
Two groups of words that could each stand alone as a sentence cannot be joined by a comma alone. You have three legal joins: a period, a semicolon by itself, or a comma plus a joining word. Check that your fix uses exactly one of those and adds no stray commas.

Extended response: Two weeks' notice for a work schedule

Redline Grocery, a chain with eleven stores in the Twin Cities, posts employee schedules on Thursday night for the week beginning Monday. Managers may change a posted shift up to four hours before it starts, and last year the company changed roughly one shift in six after posting it. A city council member has proposed an ordinance requiring employers with more than fifty workers to post schedules fourteen days in advance and to pay one extra hour of wages for any shift changed after posting. Redline says the ordinance would force it to schedule fewer people on busy days, since it could no longer add staff on short notice. At a public hearing, two Redline cashiers told the council that unpredictable shifts had cost them a child-care spot and a seat in a night class. The council votes next month.

Your task: Write a response of about 200 to 300 words taking a position on whether the council should pass the ordinance. Support your position with specific details from the scenario as evidence. Somewhere in your response, state the strongest point the other side would make and explain why your position still holds. Plan before you write, and leave yourself time at the end to reread what you wrote.

One way someone might answer this

The council should pass the ordinance. Two weeks of notice is not a favor to workers. It is the minimum a person needs to build a life around a job.

The scenario shows what happens without it. Redline changed about one shift in six after posting, so a worker reading the schedule on Thursday night still could not count on it. That is not a rare mistake; that is how the company runs. Two cashiers told the council what it costs them. One lost a child-care spot and the other lost a seat in a night class. Child care and school are the two things most likely to move somebody out of a low-wage job, and an unpredictable schedule takes both away.

Redline says it would have to schedule fewer people on busy days because it could not add staff at the last minute. That is a fair worry, and the stores do have to cover the floor. But the ordinance does not ban late changes. It puts a price on them: one extra hour of pay. A manager who truly needs another cashier on Saturday can still call one in and pay for it. What the ordinance ends is treating a worker's whole week as something that can be moved at no cost.

If Redline wants people available on short notice, it can pay for that. The council should vote yes.

1My claimThe council shouldthe ordinance.2Evidence AA fact a reader can check:2Evidence BA different fact:Facts in the scenario to choose fromAbout 1 shift in 6 was changed after postingSchedules post on Thursday night for MondayOrdinance: 14 days notice, 1 extra hour of payA cashier lost a seat in a night class3The other side saysFewer staff on busy days.4My answer: It is true thatbut
Picture it Plan your schedule argument

Fill the plan before you write. Pick two facts a reader could check, name what Redline would say, then answer it with the frame: It is true that, but.

Module III · 35 points · Ten questions, no calculator on the first four

Modeling with data: rates, trends, and what a graph says

Numbers get used to argue things: that a program works, that one option beats another, that a trend is going the right way. This module is about testing those claims: finding the rate under the raw totals, tracking a percent back to its base, and reading a table for what it actually says instead of what someone says it says.

What you'll do: convert totals into rates, reverse a percentage to find its base, read a table for the change it records, and decide when a mean lies and a median does not.

Axis starts at 0020406050A54BSales ($ thousands)Axis starts at 48485052545650A54BSales ($ thousands)
Picture it The same data, two scales

Both graphs show the same two numbers, 50 and 54. Where the axis starts changes how big the gap looks.

Question 1 Math · Rates
A transit yard is comparing two shuttle vans on the same route.

Van A: 468 miles on 18 gallons of fuel
Van B: 322 miles on 14 gallons of fuel

Which van uses fuel more efficiently, and by what measure?
Fuel used and miles driven are both different, so totals alone can't settle it. Put each van on the same footing: miles for every one gallon.
Question 2 Math · Rates
A liquid medication is prescribed at 12 mg for every 8 kg of body weight. A patient weighs 54 kg. Doses are measured to the nearest milligram, and the ratio holds at every weight: there is no rounding up to whole 8 kg steps. What is the correct dose?
Find the dose for a single kilogram first, then scale that up to the patient's weight. Check which number goes on top of the fraction before you divide.
Question 3 Math · Percent
A job-training program reports how many graduates came back within three years because a job did not work out.

2019: 240 graduates, 96 came back
2023: 300 graduates, 90 came back

The program claims the return rate dropped. By what percent did the return rate decrease from 2019 to 2023?
Turn each year into a rate first: returns out of releases. Then measure the drop against the starting rate, not the ending one. A drop of ten percentage points is not the same as a drop of ten percent.
Question 4 Math · Percent
A community kitchen served 253 meals on Friday. That was 15% more than the number of meals it served on Thursday. How many meals did it serve on Thursday?
Thursday is the base here, not Friday. Ask yourself what 253 is 115% of, then undo the increase: taking 15% off Friday is not the same operation.
Question 5 Math · Tables & graphs
Outdoor temperature was recorded every three hours at one site.

Time: Temperature
6 a.m.: 41°F
9 a.m.: 47°F
12 p.m.: 55°F
3 p.m.: 59°F
6 p.m.: 50°F
9 p.m.: 39°F

Between which two consecutive readings did the temperature change by the greatest number of degrees?
Work down the column and write the gap between each pair of neighboring readings. Size of change is what's asked: a fall counts the same as a rise, and the highest reading is not the biggest change.
Question 6 Math · Tables & graphs
Four sites run the same job-training program. The table shows how many people enrolled and how many finished.

Site (Enrolled) Completed
North (120) 84
East (60) 45
South (200) 130
West (40) 32

Which site had the highest completion rate?
A rate compares completions to that site's own enrollment. The site with the most finishers is not automatically the site with the best rate: divide before you decide.
Question 7 Math · Linear models
A student tracks typing speed during a training program. After 2 weeks the speed is 24 words per minute. After 6 weeks it is 40 words per minute. The speed increases by the same amount each week. Which equation models the speed w after t weeks in the program?
Get the weekly increase from the change in speed over the change in weeks. Then work backwards to week 0: the starting speed is not the week-2 speed.
Question 8 Math · Linear models
A physical therapist models a patient's walking distance with the equation d = 150 + 45w, where d is the number of meters the patient walks in one session and w is the number of weeks the patient has been in the program. Which statement does the model support?
One number is where the patient started: the distance when w is zero. The other is attached to w, so it's what gets added per week. Don't add the two together, and don't drop the starting distance when you predict ahead.
Question 9 Math · Statistics
Seven workers on a loading crew were timed completing the same task. Their times, in minutes, were:

22, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 94

The 94 belongs to a worker whose equipment jammed partway through. A supervisor wants a single number describing how long the task typically takes this crew. Which measure should the supervisor use, and what is its value?
Compute both, then look at what the 94 does to each one. With seven values in order, count carefully to the true middle position.
Question 10 Math · Probability
A program tracked 120 students by whether they attended tutoring and whether they completed the course.

Group, Completed, Did not complete, Total
Attended tutoring | 48 | 12 | 60
No tutoring | 30 | 30 | 60
Total | 78 | 42 | 120

One student is chosen at random from the 120. Given that the chosen student attended tutoring, what is the probability that the student completed the course?
The words "given that" shrink the pool you are drawing from. Decide which row or column is now the whole group, and use that number as the denominator.
Module IV · 30 points · One investigation, six questions

Testing a claim: what the evidence can carry

Every claim rests on a method. In this module you take one investigation apart piece by piece: what was changed, what was held steady, what the numbers actually say, and exactly where the conclusion runs past its evidence.

What you'll do: name the variables, find the factor nobody controlled, read the table for its real shape, and separate what the data show from what the researcher concluded.

Sorts the workersReported hours ofsleep, in five groups(4 or less to 8 or more)Measured for eachReaction time inmilliseconds (bestof five trials)Held the same for all 18 workersTest at10:45 p.m.Same tablet,same light flashSame break room,same lightingNot tracked: could differ between groups?What workersate?Childrenat home?Hours already workedthis week
Picture it Sorting the details of Andre's study

Sort every detail of the study into one of four boxes. Notice what stayed the same for all 18 workers, and what Andre never tracked.

The investigation

Andre Whitfield supervises the overnight shift at a warehouse in north Minneapolis. He noticed that orders filled late in the week came back with more incorrect items in them, and he wondered whether sleep was the reason. He posted a sign-up sheet in the break room, and 18 workers from his shift volunteered. Each one wrote down how many hours of sleep they had gotten before coming in. At 10:45 p.m., before anyone had coffee, Andre gave every volunteer the same reaction-time test on the same tablet: a light flashes on the screen and you tap it as fast as you can. Each worker ran five trials in the same break room under the same lighting, and Andre recorded each worker's best time in milliseconds. He then sorted the results into groups by hours of sleep. Andre did not track what the workers ate, whether they had young children at home, or how many hours each had already worked that week. In his write-up, he reported that average reaction times were slower in the groups that slept less, and concluded that the warehouse should require eight hours of sleep because sleep loss causes picking errors.

Andre measuredReaction time of18 volunteers fromone overnight shiftAndre concludedSleep loss causespicking errorsin orders?1What is missing between the two boxes?2A sentence the data can carryReported sleep andgo together.
Picture it What he measured, what he claimed

Compare the two boxes. Name what is missing between them, then finish the sentence with only what the data can carry.

The data

Average best-of-five reaction time by reported hours of sleep, 18 volunteers from one overnight shift.

Hours of sleep  |  Workers  |  Average reaction time (ms)
4 or less  |  3  |  412
5  |  4  |  389
6  |  5  |  351
7  |  4  |  322
8 or more  |  2  |  318

Average reaction time (ms) by reported sleepStep from row above4 or less(3 workers)4125 hours(4 workers)389down 236 hours(5 workers)351down 387 hours(4 workers)322down 298 or more(2 workers)318down 4Hatched bars: only 4 ms apart. The gain flattens out.
Picture it Reaction time by hours of sleep

Read the size of each step, not only the direction. Where do the steps get big, and where do they nearly stop?

Question 1 Science · Variables
Which of the following is the dependent variable in Andre's investigation?
The dependent variable is the one the researcher measures to see whether it responds. Ask what number Andre wrote down for each worker at the end of the test.
Question 2 Science · Controls
Andre assumes that sleep is the main thing separating his groups. Which factor he failed to control gives the strongest reason to doubt that assumption?
An uncontrolled factor only damages a comparison if it can pass two tests: it could differ from group to group, and it could affect what was measured. Run each option through both.
Question 3 Science · Data
Which statement is best supported by the table?
Read the numbers in order and note the size of each step, not only the direction. Also check whether a statement is about group averages or about individual people.
Question 4 Science · Correlation
Andre concludes that sleep loss causes picking errors. What is the biggest problem with that conclusion?
Line the conclusion up against the method. Ask what was actually measured, and then ask whether "these two move together" has quietly turned into "one makes the other happen."
Question 5 Science · Sampling
Andre wants to apply his finding to every warehouse worker in the company. Which feature of his sample is the strongest reason for caution?
Generalizing means carrying a result from the people who were tested over to people who were not. Ask who had any chance of ending up in this study, and who never did.
Question 6 Science · Next steps
Which follow-up investigation would best test whether short sleep actually causes slower reaction times?
To test a cause, you want the suspected cause to change on purpose while everything else stays as steady as possible. Ask which plan does the changing instead of only watching.
Module V · 30 points · One document, five questions

Reading an argument in a primary source

Every document was written by someone who wanted something from someone. In this module you take one piece of testimony apart: what it claims, what it counts as proof, what it quietly assumes, and who it never mentions at all.

What you'll do: find the claim, name the audience and what the speaker wants from them, separate evidence from assertion, and locate the assumption the argument never defends.

Take any argument apart with four questionsClaimWhat does the speaker wantdone? Every other sentenceworks for this one.AudienceWho is in the room, and whatcan only those people dotonight?EvidenceCould you count it or look itup? If not, it is only said(an assertion).AssumptionWhat must be true for thecase to work, but is neverargued?gap1234Evidence: you can check itAssertion: you must take his wordAnd who is never mentioned?Their side is missing.
Picture it Four questions to take an argument apart

Ask these four questions of any document. Notice the difference between evidence you could check and an assertion you must take on someone's word. Ask who is never mentioned.

Primary source

Testimony on the Proposed Curfew Ordinance

Harlan Pike, chairman of the Citizens' Committee for Orderly Streets, before the Public Safety Committee of the City Council, Minneapolis, 1938. This document was written for this module; the speaker and committee are invented.

Gentlemen of the committee: I speak for four hundred householders of the Sixth Ward, and I ask you for one thing: the ordinance before you, that no person under eighteen years be found upon the public streets after ten o'clock at night unless in the company of a parent or carrying a written errand from one.

I am told the rule is hard. I answer that the hour is harder. Of the ninety-one boys and girls brought before the juvenile court of this city last year, sixty-one were taken up between ten at night and four in the morning. Those are the court's own figures, and no one disputes them.

What business has a young person on the pavement at that hour? Not work, not school, not the church, not the errand of a mother. Every parent in the ward can tell you what is out there at midnight, and it is not the making of a citizen. If we do not act, we shall lose a generation to the poolroom and the alley.

Some will say the fault lies in the wage, in the crowded room, in the mills that have stood closed these four years. I do not deny it. A boy with a job and a bed of his own is a boy less often in trouble. But this council cannot raise a wage tonight, and it can clear a sidewalk tonight. We must use the authority we have.

Nor need you fear that the ordinance will fall on the innocent. The officer on his beat may be trusted to know the difference between a young man on an honest errand and one on the loose. Give him the authority, and he will send a child home before the night makes something worse of him.

Harlan Pike, 1938: what does each paragraph do?Paragraph and his wordsWhat this paragraph does, in your wordsMark one"I speak for four hundredhouseholders ... I ask youfor one thing""Of the ninety-one boys andgirls brought before thejuvenile court ... last year""Every parent in the ward cantell you what is out thereat midnight""this council cannot raise awage tonight, and it can cleara sidewalk tonight""The officer on his beat maybe trusted to know thedifference"checksaidchecksaidchecksaidchecksaidchecksaid23456Mark "check" if you could count or look it up. Mark "said" if it is only his word.Then circle the paragraph that holds his claim, and underline the step he never argues.
Picture it Pike's testimony, paragraph by paragraph

Write what each paragraph does, then mark whether it holds something you could check or only his word. Circle his claim. Underline the step he never argues.

Question 1 Social Studies · Main claim
Which statement best expresses the speaker's main claim?
A main claim is the sentence every other sentence is working for. Ask yourself: if the committee agreed with the speaker on only one point tonight, which point would give him what he came into the room to get?
Question 2 Social Studies · Point of view
The speech is delivered to the members of a city council committee. What does the speaker want from that particular audience?
Purpose is measured by the action a speaker asks for, not by the feelings the words stir up. Look at who is sitting in front of him and ask what those people, and only those people, have the power to do that night.
Question 3 Social Studies · Evidence
Which sentence functions as evidence rather than as assertion?
Evidence is something a listener could go and check, count, or look up. Warnings, common sense, and confident language can carry a room, but none of them are facts a person could verify: test each sentence by asking where you would go to show it is false.
Question 4 Social Studies · Assumption
The speaker's case rests on one idea he never stops to argue for. Which idea is it?
An assumption is a step the argument needs but never defends. Look for the sentence that would bring the whole case down if it turned out to be false, then notice that the speaker offers no reason at all to believe it: he tells the committee not to worry.
Question 5 Social Studies · Context
What does this testimony tell you about the city at the moment it was given?
A document is a snapshot of what already existed and what did not. Read for the machinery the speaker takes for granted (the offices, records, and routines he mentions in passing) and then for the one thing he has to stand up and ask for, because it is not there yet.
Final tally

Your Level 4 score

0 / 160
Module 1 · Reading 0 / 35
Module 2 · Writing 0 / 30
Module 3 · Math 0 / 35
Module 4 · Science 0 / 30
Module 5 · Social Studies 0 / 30
Work through the modules above. Your score will update as you go.